4.2

Somewhere Beyond The Sea

By TJ. KLUNE

Format:Hardcover

This is the hugely-anticipated sequel to TJ Klune's The House in the Cerulean Sea, one of the best loved fantasy novels of the past decade. It's also a New York Times and Washington Post bestseller. A magical house. A secret past. A summons that could change everything. Arthur Parnassus lives a good life built on the ashes of a bad one. He's the master of a strange orphanage on a distant and peculiar island, and he hopes to soon be the adoptive father to the six dangerous and magical children who live there. Arthur works hard and loves with his whole heart so none of the children ever feel the neglect and pain that he once felt as an orphan on that very same island so long ago. He is not alone: joining him is the love of his life, Linus Baker, a former caseworker in the Department In Charge of Magical Youth. And there's the island's sprite, Zoe Chapelwhite, and her girlfriend, Mayor Helen Webb. Together, they will do anything to protect the children. But when Arthur is summoned to make a public statement about his dark past, he finds himself at the helm of a fight for the future that his family, and all magical people, deserve. And when a new magical child hopes to join them on their island home - one who finds power in calling himself monster, a name that Arthur worked so hard to protect his children from - Arthur knows they're at a breaking point: their family will either grow stronger than ever or fall apart. Welcome back to Marsyas Island. This is Arthur's story. Somewhere Beyond the Sea is a story of resistance, lovingly told, about the daunting experience of fighting for the life you want to live and doing the work to keep it. Praise for The House in the Cerulean Sea: 'I loved it. It is like being wrapped up in a big gay blanket. Simply perfect' - V.E. Schwab, author of The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue 'It will renew your faith in humanity' - Terry Brooks, author of the Shannara series 'A witty, wholesome fantasy that's likely to cause heart-swelling' - The Washington Post

Science Fiction & Fantasy
Hardcover
First published 2024

What's Bookie?

  • Free delivery in Germany.
  • Find your perfect next read.
  • Track to motivate you to read more.
  • Connect with people like you.

Popular Reviews(4)

4.2(40 ratings)
L Dot RichReviewed by L Dot Rich

A wonderful sequel to The House in the Cerulean Sea, and once again, reading it feels like your heart is being wrapped in a warm blanket. There are some clear parallels to Harry Potter (Order of the Phoenix), likely as a deliberate gesture against JK Rowling. Unfortunately, the ending felt a little too simple.

Katja SchmidtReviewed by Katja Schmidt

Amazing, wonderful book full of magic and love and hope. Everybody should read it, especially in hateful times like these.

ElenaReviewed by Elena

5,5/10 -2,75/5 Overall a fine book that I enjoyed but it had some issues that I couldn't overlook. There's a question I asked myself when I started reading the book and it kept popping back into my mind throughout it: Why did we need this? This is by no means a bad book, it's very beautiful and wholesome and has a wonderful message. I like the characters and their relationships. But… what was the point of it all? The first one had a story to tell, a message to bring across. This one? I feel like it didn't really add anything new to it, really. The first one was already standing fully on its own and I didn't really feel like we needed a sequel. But as I loved it of course I picked up the continuation to see where it would go. As I've said, I loved book 1. Except for the ending, which was too perfect and overdone for my taste, I loved everything about it. Sadly this one read like the ending for the most part. What I liked about cerulean sea was gone and instead replaced with preachy lines and unrealistic solutions to all problems the characters faced. The story has no point, no goal, but it reads as if it should have. We just revisit the same plotlines and same themes from the last one but not as well executed. Again, what was the point of this sequel? Why could this not have been an anthology of the fun things the family does without a coherent plotline, as this book already doesn't have one? -Writing- TJ Klune is a good writer. He has his way with words and his writing is beautiful. This is the first book of his I've read in English so perhaps that's the reason, but I found that he dabbled a bit too much in the writing. What I mean by that? It's a bit pretentious sometimes. Words I've never heard, words I've rarely heard, elaborate sentence structures and that the entire book. Could be totally on me though, I'm not a native speaker. Nonetheless, I usually don't have this problem in contemporary non-medieval fantasy books. Still, beautiful writing and quite a few nice lines one could quote. In my opinion though not every character has to talk like they swallowed a thesaurus. Themewise, this missed the mark. I say this as a leftie with everything it entails, but I felt like the “wokeness” was amped to a ten and incredibly in your face. The division between good and evil here also didn't convince me. The narrative makes it a point to tell you that governments are evil, that the magic thingie is evil and that they're evil for evils sake and nothing else. This is flat out stated, that this is the only reason for the antagonists to be evil. In book 1 we saw Linus intending to do good but doing the opposite. The way to hell is paved with good intentions and all. How come this only applies to Linus? It seems like all nuance has been left. Usually I don't mind evil for evils sake if you keep it simple, but if you make a second book discussing the topic again, I expect a nuanced discussion and not a step back. Many questions I had myself reading the first book were asked here and at first it made me really happy, but then I read the next sentences and realized that all those questions would go unanswered and all the discussions killed before they started. <spoiler> E.g. one child asked how they were any different by making their own echo chamber. And there's just… no answer to that? </spoiler> I also wasn't completely happy with this is in book 1 but this conflict was bigger here so I have to complain more about it of course. The book wants us to be kind, yes? Not to have prejudices and treat everyone equal? Clearly a metaphor (or an allgory? I'm always confused about the two) for how marginalized groups are treated. Now, it's not just this book that has this problem, many books who use the same metaphor struggle with this, but this is the main plot here so it's very hard to ignore. The metaphor doesn't work. Queer people, people of color, disabled people, all the marginalized groups, they're the same as the rest. We're all humans and we're all equal. Magical people though, are not. Lucy is the antichrist (whatever that entails for the worldbuilding…), he can just snap people out of existence. The magical people here are different from humans and they could pose a threat to them. This is a real thing. Straight people have no reason to be scared of queer folks. Humans do have a reason to be scared of magical folks, though. Now, it still stands that these are children and as such they don't deserve how the magical thingie treats them and that they want to rip apart a family. And of course inequality still is wrong and none of the groups should stand above the other. But thematically this just needs to be done differently. It was okay in the first book because Linus approached the orphanage with the opposing viewpoint and he had to learn that despite of all the magic these children were just children. But in the second book it would only be fair to then actually handle the question that is frequently asked: but what if? Instead it's just brushed off and it's only said by the villains who shout unreasonable things alongside it, which completely invalidates the claim. Tj klune didn't want to have the discussion? Fine, but then he shouldn't have written a second book where he had nothing new to say. We already know that these children are not a threat, as we've learned it in book 1. This one provides zero new messaging and discussions. It just repeats the same statements over and over again while digging itself deeper into the hole of an ill-fitting metaphor. There's also a few lines that made me question my eyesight. First theres a line Sal says about being “human, magical and Black” like… being black and human are not two different things. I get what the author intended, but it sounds so wrong. Counting off human and magical as opposites and then black… ugh. But I know it wasn't intended that way. Then there's a line some anti protestors say about what if the children think being magical is normal, being magical is a choice. This is clearly the line anti lgbtq+ folks use, copied directly. It's just…. Weird. Again, gay people are not a threat to other humans, while magical beings could be. And since you are factually born as a magical being, with DNA and wings and all, it obviously isn't a choice. Don't get me wrong, sexuality isn't any more of a choice, but there's at least some wiggle room why people could think so. But this? It's like saying “being black is a choice”. No one does that because it's ridiculous. No right winger will claim that because it's just wrong even if you are not that smart. This line is stupid in our world already and it will never fail to make me roll my eyes, but in this universe it's just ridiculous and has no reasoning. One thing I am deeply uncomfortable with, and I am very biased because I'm vegan, is the whole Frank the fish debacle. I am not stranger to omnivores and I know that the characters in books mostly are. This also isn't the first time that a discussion about vegetarianism has been opened up in a book and in the end gone against it. Of course I will always feel uncomfortable with it but usually I can see why the characters act like that or why the conclusion was made. I prefer my books not to dabble in the topic because I'm never happy with the outcome but there are wasys to handle it that don't make me straight up angry. Here I felt deeply offended. So we learn that chauncey can talk to fish and not only that, fish are also sentient, all of them. Sentient in a human like way, making friends and having names. Of course that is quite a big reveal and has lots of implications. And this is followed by Chauncey trying to eat the fish?!?!? I was absolutely flabbergasted at that scene. But okay, I was willing to let it slide. But then we get arthur being saved by said fish. While the whole conversation about fish being sentient is never brought up again and no character seems to have acted upon that, this fish and his l school save arthur. The man who - from what we know- would eat them, had he not had those interactions with them. Perhaps he will one day, when he buys fish in the village and it just so happens to be frank who bit the hook. Sorry, I find that really disgusting. That's far beyond my tolerance. You can't just drop a bombshell like that and not interact with it. I was not happy with how eragon (minor spoiler) dealed with vegetarianism but at least the animals there are just sentient as in alive, here they fucking talk and have names!!!! Did tj klune not think this through? He created an universe where all fish are sentient like humans are but humans go on and eat them. I say this as a vegan who doesn't eat animal already with them having a “lesser” conscience than humans. In this book they are the same and nobody talks about it again. People just kill human-like fish and it's made the butt of the joke. Honestly, I thought about dnfing when Chauncey ate the fish. I was so disgusted but I decided to be stronger and stick with it. Even if the implications made me tear up. But really I don't have any understanding left after the saving scene. I'm sure I'll be quite alone in this but in my opinion this was tasteless and foul. </spoiler> -Characters- We meet three major new characters. David, the new addition to the family, Jeanine, the big bad of the season and Ms Marblemaw, the new inspector. Other than that, the story mainly stays with the characters we already know. Our perspective shifts from Linus over to Arthur and as such it's not the same. For some reason I could never get as invested into his journey as i was with Linus, despite liking arthur. I suppose part of it was that the voice of the narrator isn't different enough, making it feel similar, but lacking Linus charm. Arthur starts off as a pretty perfect character so he has little conflict to deal with. The one he deals with here could have been really good, if it was explored in more than one chapter. <spoiler>It's interesting to see him deal with anger and finally exploding after so much time. I love this kind lf conflict. But honestly? This isn't the book for it. The conflict is shown and dealt with in one chapter. And I get why. This would be such a heavy topic to deal with and this is a cozy fantasy. In the end the result simply is that Arthur lacks conflict and growth for his character. </spoiler> Sadly we also don't learn much about his oh so mysterious past. I think Arthur was much better suited as a main character but not protagonist, like in book 1. And is it just me or is Linus kind of missing? I don't know, perhaps it's because it's been so long since I've read the first book but he feels different. He also doesn't get many moments where he's just… Linus. He's always in the role of the kids parent or Arthur's partner. This will sound so shitty when I say this but why did we need David? It's not that I don't like him, I actually found him to be a charming and entertaining character. It's just that he serves no real point. I probably wouldn't be this fussy about his character if the book as a whole had more of a reason. He is a great addition to the family, but no one would have missed him, had he not been here. My point just is that he has no purpose on being added narratively. He doesn't change other characters, he is not vital for the events of the book, poses no hurdle for anyone and the family dynamic wasn't missing anything. Since the story also spend a comparatively big amount out of time on the plot and not the simple family building moments his purpose also just isn't being the new addition. The plot isn't “how do we deal with a new child?”. Jeanine initially was a fantastic villain. Evil and charming in a way that made you hate her but also appreciate her presence. The last bit of the book ruined it. Villains who just scream unreasonable things are the most boring ones. <spoiler>Lucy looking into her soul and only seeing black didn't make that better.</spoiler> It completely flew past me that she is basically supposed to be jk Rowling. Which I don't know how to feel about, because I hate what she's been doing and saying the past couple of years ans yet it leaves a bitter taste in my mouth. By making a real person - which you hate - a person in your story you derive the character of any nuance or growth. Ms. Marblemaw is the biggest disappointment. While she never is charming or interesting, we spend so much time with her, that I would have appreciated it if she was more interesting. <spoiler> She is the antithesis to linus, the inspector who came and wasn't fazed, who remained “evil”. Her character is incredibly confusing to me. I thought she would be the anti-thesis to Linus in the way of having good intentions just like him but still failing to see the harm she creates. Weirdly this is supported by her multiple times showing signs of kindness and faltering. When she talks to Jeanine Rowder she seems to be against what she's doing and seems to have doubts. But then it all vanishes and she becomes a figure of evil. I would have loved seeing why she decides on keeping on going. Does Jeanine have something she pressures her with? Does she have good intentions now or not? What made her give in??? It's also disappointing that the glimpse of a sad past is for Jeanine. It would've fit Ms marblemaw much much better. She doesn't need to be relatable or redeemed, but make her interesting!! </spoiler> As in the first book i love all the children. I couldn't even say who my favorite is because every one of them has a special charm the others don't and they're all incredibly entertaining and adorable. Still, it's a bit weird is how often the children speak incredibly maturily. Sometimes this fit and it could even be funny, but sometimes it was incredibly out of place. Most of the kids would drop these specific lines but more than all Sal does it. He so often plays the mature role that it feels wrong. Sometimes he feels more like a friend than a child. When he had those important, serious things to say they often weren't questioned or challenged at all. Not that I think he's wrong, but it was basically as if the adults were wrong and Sal was right. When he asks why the kids need to try to appease the dicomy and not the other way around he is obviously right but that doesn't diminish that he simply has to adjust. It's annoying because this book directly rips real phrases and issues from the real world and directly implants them into the book (as I've explained that often doesn't even work) but then it finds unrealistic solutions for it. I'm fine with a bit of dispension of disbelief for a cozy story but if you take real problems and add them to your story without any nuance or subtlety it doesn't work. The parents accept what Sal says and go with his suggestions that wouldn't fly irl at all. I can't tell a trans kid in a transphobic neighborhood to just do what they want because yes, the transphobes are wrong! They could get lynched, hatecrimed, etc! If you intend to make a metaphor in a fictional story about real problems then it has to be applicable too. This problem arises so many times with the children, especially with Sal. -Relationships- I think arthur and Linus are shaping up to be amazing parents. Many things they do i would do the same. I applaud them for their patience and gentleness. What i don't appreciate is … I don't know how to call it. The lack of boundaries? From the children towards the parents. This is especially a conflict that arises between the parents and Sal, who as a 15 year old obviously has lots to say and wants to be involved. This is fine, it's realistic and it fits Sal. It's only fair that he wants to be involved in plans and not left out. What isn't, is that this means ALL the kids. Sal is 15, but Lucy is 7. <spoiler> Arthur was not only right in wanting to protect the children from the threats, he was actually wrong in giving in and involving them. Sal could have been involved! He is indeed old enough. But the other kids?? No!!!! If someone were to threaten my siblings I would fight with my tooth and nails not to involve them in it, except for the older ones. Children have no business in this. </spoiler> I'm a bit sad that we got so little moments of Arthur and Linus together. Ofc we get them being cute and couply but I miss… the relationship building, i guess? It just feels like when you married your spouse in started valley and now they sit around on your farm and occasionally you give them a like smooch. I miss the simple interactions and discussions between the two. But this is not focus of the story. -Plot/Pacing- The first 40 % are spent on the hearing Linus and arthur go to and that was definitely the worst part of the book. It was boring, lacked charm and the children weren't there. I don't get why that part was so long. All it did was announce a thing that was already decided beforehand. We learn nothing new about Arthur. Once we get those it gets much better, only to be followed by an even worse candyfloss ending than the first book had. The stakes also felt incredibly weird. They were so high bur didn't feel like that at all? <spoiler> This already started at the hearing where author made snarky comments and refused following protocol. The comments were funny, I admit, but I was also thinking “what on earth is he doing?”. I feel like the threat of the inspector wasn't treated adequately either. First they make such a big deal out of it, everyone is super scared and “what if the kids get taken away”, but then the characters turn around and act nothing like that. Arthur continues on making jokes towards Ms Marblemaw that are absolutely not going go help and David is allowed to be there. I beg your pardon??? He doesn't want to hide, I get that, but he could just get taken away if you don't do that? It's mere luck for the characters that Zoe had deus ex machina powers hidden under her wings or else he would have just been taken away. I get that appeasing her wouldn't have worked because she was dead set on making them fail in the first place, but why not even try? Of course making jokes and being unprofessional to a bureaucrat with a stick up her ass won't work!!! And why were they all so shocked that she had only those intentions, when that was so clear anyway? You can't on one hand make the characters scared of her, then act totally reckless while thinking that she is genuine in her efforts. Had the characters believed from the start that their actions didn't matter anyway, that would be a different story. This is a cozy fantasy so the reader obviously knows how the book is going to end so the only thing you have to keep the stakes alive is to make the characters be stressed and anxious bc of the stakes but that doesn't happen here. I am happy that they were able to found the country of marsyas as a new safe haven but the way they got to it was just so cringe. The whole interaction between Jeanine and the family was so cartoonish and boring and then we get a magical girl-esque uprooting of an island which was…. So out of place in this book. I just had an anime in mind when the light balls came out of everyone's chest. </spoiler> -Conclusion- The story seems to be hinting at a third book and should that come, I will not read it. Not because I think it will be bad, but because I think the story has already been told and if book 2 provided nothing new, so won't a further installment. Quite unsure how I want to rate this because I have so many problems with it but overall I enjoyed it.

James LückReviewed by James Lück

Alright 4.75 stars. Definitely worth it was so sceptical because I loved the first one. I didn't realise how I missed the characters so much, it's like something was filled knowing the story continued

Similar Books